← News

Cantwell tells Lutnick Commerce let Nvidia's best chips reach China

Sen. Maria Cantwell sent Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick a letter accusing his department of failing to enforce export controls on advanced AI chips. It lands the same day Commerce rolled out a new rule aimed at exactly that problem.

The new remote-access rule shows Commerce is moving, but Cantwell's letter is the case that it moved late. With Democrats taking both chambers in January, per CNBC, this reads less like a letter and more like an agenda for hearings.

On Monday, Nov. 16, Sen. Maria Cantwell, Democrat of Washington and ranking member of the Senate Commerce Committee, released a letter to Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick. The letter is dated Sunday, Nov. 15. She wants him to use the department's authority to stop advanced AI chips from reaching companies with ties to China. Ranking member means the top senator of the minority party on that committee. Those lines are the committee's press release.

Her letter says: "The Department of Commerce has resisted efforts to restrict companies flagged as national security threats, weakened safeguards, and left open pathways for the PRC to train advanced AI models using sensitive American technology." And: "These failures to carry out the law help give away America's technology advantage in AI." PRC is the People's Republic of China. Those quotations are hers, in the letter the committee posted.

The charges, as the release lists them. Commerce refused to close the loophole that lets Chinese companies train AI models on American chips sitting in overseas data centers. It ignored repeated warnings from the Treasury, State, and Defense departments to restrict Megaspeed, the Singapore company CNBC ties to the Jensen Huang scandal. Reports, which the letter cites, say Commerce suspended its Megaspeed investigation after outreach from Nvidia's general counsel. And Commerce twice suspended a rule that extended export restrictions to subsidiaries majority-owned by companies already on the blacklist. A blacklist, here, is the list of companies barred from receiving sensitive U.S. technology. Those four charges are the release's.

She points to the Export Control Reform Act of 2018. That is the law that gives Commerce the power to control exports of sensitive technology. The release says the department already has that authority and has not used it.

She also raises conflict questions. Lutnick's sons control Cantor Fitzgerald, which she says held $1.2 billion in Nvidia stock when he was nominated. The administration's 25 percent fee on certain Nvidia chip sales to China, she writes, could create "a perverse financial incentive to approve exports." The stock figure and the fee line are hers, in the letter. They are an argument about incentives, not a finding that a sale was approved because of the fee.

The timing. Lutnick is set to travel to China with the President this week for the APEC summit. APEC is the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting. The Commerce Department did not immediately respond to CNBC's request for comment. The trip is in the committee release. The no-comment line is CNBC's.

Same day, Commerce issued a rule that requires a license before overseas data centers can serve China-headquartered companies with serious computing power. Senate Banking Chair Tim Scott has called Jensen Huang and Lutnick to testify in December. CNBC also notes that Democrats will take both the House and the Senate in January. The rule is the separate filing linked beside this one. The hearing call and the January line are CNBC's.

The picture is Sen. Maria Cantwell in her official U.S. Senate portrait, smiling, in a tan jacket. It is a public-domain Senate photograph. It is not a picture from Monday's letter. The credit is U.S. Senate, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

In plain terms, the top Democrat on the Senate Commerce Committee told the commerce secretary, in a letter dated Sunday and released Monday, that his department left the door open for China's labs to train on America's best chips. She names an overseas-data-center loophole, warnings about Megaspeed that she says were ignored, a paused investigation, and a rule on blacklisted companies' subsidiaries that she says was suspended twice. She also asks whether a family firm's Nvidia stake and a 25 percent export fee pull the department toward approving sales. Commerce had not answered CNBC by the time of that report. A letter is not a case a court has heard.

RELATED

ONLINE…

Comments

guidelines

Loading…

Loading…

Sources